Luscious BOLD sparkle eyeliner in metallic silver :Review and swatches

hi girls
luscious has so many products to offer from eyes to lips.This product is BOLD metallic eyeliner pencil in silver from their eye liner range.I had high hopes form this product but it turned me down.Read my review to find out more.

 What Luscious says,
 

Luscious BOLD Metallic Eyeliner

Bold color that makes a statement. Eight glorious shades of sparkling eyeliner that deliver powerful, vibrant color. A waterproof, smudge-proof, fade-proof formula that glides on for a long-lasting finish. At last, an eyeliner pencil that keeps its promises!       MY experience I have oily lids,so majority eye pencils smudge on my lids.I bought this eye liner by reading the description of the product written on  luscious website.But the product is actually not what it claims.I applied it to my eye lids and it only stayed their for half n hour...it even started to fade in 15 min after application.It is not water proof even...I also applied it to my lower lash line,but the results were same.It is not pigmented enough,one has to swipe it many times on lids to get desired colour.It is creamy in texture so it glides on lids smoothl,but as it is very creamy in texture so it smudge easily.below is the swatch picture on my hand, Overall i am not using it and wont buy any liner of this line again.May be this will work for dry skin but definately not a product for oily lids.  My Ratings 1/5 ,Not recommended for oily lids Price And Availibility It is available at all leading stores of country and also on luscious website.you can get this in Rs.285/- hope you like my review and find it helpful.    love xx  take care